Device Tree Linux

Top Device Tree page

Device Tree Framework Source Code
The device tree framework source code is located in drivers/of/.

Code for manipulating the flattened device tree (FDT) is is scripts/dtc/libfdt.

libfdt is imported from the external project maintained in
 * https://git.kernel.org/cgit/utils/dtc/dtc.git
 * git clone git://git.kernel.org/pub/scm/utils/dtc/dtc.git

Linux Man pages
Linux man pages are a work in progress.

The current version of the pages can be downloaded or built locally.

disabled nodes
Linux has widespread use of the "status" property to indicate that a node does not exist. This is used to create a generic .dtsi file that defines all of the potential components of a device which might contain many different functions. When the device is used in a system, many of the functions might not be routed to connectors or might not be usable due to needing pins that are multiplexed with other devices that are active. The convention is to set the "status" property of such functions to "disabled" in the .dtsi file, then the system .dts file that includes the .dtsi will change the "status" property of functions that should be enabled to "ok".

Some kernel code does not check the node "status" property before trying to configure, probe, or enable it.

Expect efforts to fix the kernel code to respect the "status" property.

node name case sensitivity
Node names are supposed to be case sensitive. The function that checks whether a node name matches a string may be defined by an architecture or may be the generic implementation. Due to some issues with old Macs the generic Linux implementation was case insensitive. There is an architecture defined version that is not case sensitive.

Expect this to change so that the generic node name compare function is case sensitive, and only a few select sub-architectures will not be case sensitive.

The move to a case sensitive compare began in v4.19 with commit f42b0e18f2e5cf34f73ef1b6327b49040b307a33 ("of: add node name compare helper functions"), which creates of_node_name_eq and of_node_name_prefix. Use of these functions is added in later commits.

Note that dtc has had node name case sensitivity for a long time (or maybe even from the beginning).

phandle source property
There are three distinct properties that may be the source of a node's phandle:


 * ibm,phandle
 * linux,phandle
 * phandle

Property "linux,phandle" is obsolete. If it exists, its value should be equivalent to the value of property "phandle".

Property "ibm,phandle" may be used in the IBM pSeries dynamic device tree.

phandle access in kernel (by drivers)
The "phandle" and "linux,phandle" properties may exist in device tree source and in the compiled Flattened Device Tree (FDT), aka "binary blob" or ".dtb". But the Linux kernel views the phandle values as device tree structure information instead of device tree data and thus does not store them as properties.

This results in a special rule:

DO NOT USE property access functions to access the properties: ibm,phandle linux,phandle phandle Note: other properties may contain phandle values. It is proper to use property access functions to read these values. Then the node containing the phandle value can be found via of_find_node_by_phandle(handle).

Functions to access phandles are: of_find_node_by_phandle

Functions that indirectly access phandles are: of_for_each_phandle of_parse_phandle_with_args of_parse_phandle_with_fixed_args

Location of .dts source files in Linux kernel source tree
Header files (.h files) for devictree bindings are located in include/dt-bindings/

The directory structure for the .dts and .dtsi files varies by architecture. Some architectures place all .dts files at a single level, others use two or level levels of directories.

As of Linux v4.11-rc1, the layout is:

===== arch/arc/boot/ dts ===== arch/arm/boot/ dts ===== arch/arm64/boot/ dts dts/actions dts/realtek dts/altera dts/lg dts/rockchip dts/broadcom dts/broadcom/stingray dts/broadcom/northstar2 dts/broadcom/bcm4908 dts/socionext dts/xilinx dts/bitmain dts/cavium dts/allwinner dts/sprd dts/intel dts/amlogic dts/qcom dts/toshiba dts/microchip dts/arm dts/ti dts/marvell dts/nvidia dts/freescale dts/amazon dts/hisilicon dts/amd dts/mediatek dts/apm dts/synaptics dts/zte dts/renesas dts/exynos ===== arch/c6x/boot/ dts ===== arch/csky/boot/ dts ===== arch/h8300/boot/ dts ===== arch/microblaze/boot/ dts ===== arch/mips/boot/ dts dts/netlogic dts/mti dts/ingenic dts/img dts/mscc dts/xilfpga dts/ralink dts/ni dts/loongson dts/cavium-octeon dts/lantiq dts/brcm dts/pic32 dts/qca ===== arch/nds32/boot/ dts ===== arch/nios2/boot/ dts ===== arch/openrisc/boot/ dts ===== arch/powerpc/boot/ dts dts/fsl ===== arch/riscv/boot/ dts dts/sifive dts/kendryte ===== arch/sh/boot/ dts ===== arch/xtensa/boot/ dts

discussion
A discussion of the directory layout for .dts files was triggered by the announcement of a script to move the dts files and update the makefiles [1].

Linux conventions

 * hex constants are lower case
 * use "0x" instead of "0X"
 * use a..f instead of A..F, eg 0xf instead of 0xF


 * node names
 * should begin with a character in the range 'a' to 'z', 'A' to 'Z'
 * unit-address does not have a leading "0x" (the number is assumed to be hexadecimal)
 * unit-address does not have leading zeros
 * use dash "-" instead of underscore "_"


 * label names
 * should begin with a character in the range 'a' to 'z', 'A' to 'Z'
 * should be lowercase
 * use underscore "_" instead of dash "-"


 * property names
 * should be lower case
 * should begin with a character in the range 'a' to 'z'
 * use dash "-" instead of underscore "_"

Actual usage in Linux 4.11-rc1: arch/arm/boot/dts/*

2512 unique property names 1877 use dash "-" 234 use underscore "_" 100 use both dash "-" and underscore "_" 501 use neither dash "-" nor underscore "_"

preferred style: reg =, , instead of: reg = <0x2c000 0x30 0x2d000 0x800 0x20000 0x1000>
 * tuple data
 * property data that is a tuple is more readable when grouped into tuples


 * maximum depth of device tree
 * #define FDT_MAX_DEPTH  64

Linux Preferences
Items in this section may be less firm or certain than items in "Linux Conventions".

If you can document or explain why any item should move to "Linux Conventions" please email frowand.list at gmail.com".

cpp
The Linux kernel build system preprocesses dts files with cpp before passing them to dtc. The dtc compileralso has an "/include/" directive.

Complex example 1
 * Files that are included via the "/include/" directive can not contain any cpp directives. This is because such files are not visible to cpp.
 * Although cpp can do conditional inclusion with features such as "#if" and "#ifdef" this is frowned upon.
 * Common use of cpp is for "#include" and simple "#defines" for symbolic names.
 * Bindings related include files are in include/dt-bindings/
 * More complex macros do exist, but are rare.

include/dt-bindings/pinctrl/omap.h:
 * 1) define OMAP_IOPAD_OFFSET(pa, offset)  (((pa) & 0xffff) - (offset))


 * 1) define OMAP2420_CORE_IOPAD(pa, val)   OMAP_IOPAD_OFFSET((pa), 0x0030) (val)

Complex example 2

include/dt-bindings/input/input.h:

((((row) & 0xFF) << 24) | (((col) & 0xFF) << 16) | ((code) & 0xFFFF))
 * 1) define MATRIX_KEY(row, col, code)     \

interrupts vs interrupts-extended
Should I use 1) the "interrupts" property in association with the "interrupt-parent" property or 2) the "interrupts-extended" property?

"Interrupts" is well understood and commonly used. It is ok to use that model.

The main purpose of "interrupts-extended" is to allow one device to have multiple interrupts that are handled by different controllers, without introducing a (more complex) "interrupt-map" property in the parent.

#address-cells and #size-cells
--- ePAPR

2.3.5 #address-cells and #size-cells 'The #address-cells and #size-cells properties are not inherited from ancestors in the device tree. They shall be      explicitly defined.'

--- Linux

#address-cells defaults to 2 #size-cells defaults to 1 dtc may warn that the default is being used.

aliases node
--- ePAPR

3.3 aliases node 'A client program may use an alias property name to refer to      a full device path as all or part of its string value.'

'A client program, when considering a string as a device path, shall detect and use the alias.'

--- Linux

of_find_node_by_path and of_find_node_opts_by_path check whether the path begins with "/". If it does not, then the first element must be a property in the aliases node. That first element is replaced with the value of the property in the aliases node.

It is not known whether other code (such as drivers) is aware of  the requirement to be aware of aliases.

Linux also has a concept of numeric id derived from the property names in the aliases node. All trailing digits in the property name are used to create the "id". The "stem" is the property name, with the trailing digits removed. For each property in  the aliases node, the tuple of stem, id, and the device tree node pointer for the path in the property's value is added to  the aliases_lookup list. A driver can use of_alias_get_id to retrieve the id for a given stem and device tree node pointer.

This is commonly used to number devices, although the practice is controversial.

chosen node
--- ePAPR

3.5 chosen node The chosen node is not required. If it was required, sections 3.1 and 3.5 would explicitly state such (for example, section 3.6 CPUS Node Properties  states 'A cpus node is required for all device trees.').

The list of required nodes is listed in section 3.1:

3.1 Base Device Node Types

'The sections that follow specify the requirements for the base set of device nodes required in an      ePAPR-compliant device tree.

All device trees shall have a root node and the following nodes shall be present at the root of all device trees: • One cpus node • At least one memory node'

--- Linux

The chosen node is required.

device_type property
--- ePAPR

2.3.11 device_type 'The device_type property was used in IEEE 1275 to describe the device’s FCode programming model. Because ePAPR does not have FCode, new use of the property is      deprecated, and it should be included only on cpu and memory nodes for compatibility with IEEE 1275–derived device trees.'

--- Linux

Many Linux bindings have a device_type property. Many of these bindings are not well documented.

Linux source code accesses this property via for_each_node_by_type, of_find_node_by_type, and by open coding. As of 4.10-rc3, the list of values searched for by for_each_node_by_type and of_find_node_by_type is:

8042     CBEA-Internal-Interrupt-Controller PowerPC-External-Interrupt-Presentation adb be     cache cpm cpu display fcu fdc interrupt-controller ipic isa memory memory-controller mic-tm mpc8xx-pic nvram open-pic pci pcie-endpoint pervasive pic-router qe     qeic serial smu soc spe tsi-bridge

labels
--- ePAPR

Appendix A Device Tree Source Format (version 1)

Node and property definitions

'Device tree nodes are defined with a node name and unit address with braces marking the start and end of the node definition. They may be preceded by a label.'

There is no note as to whether a label is allowed on the root node.

--- Linux

dtc does not allow a label on the root node.

names
Node name --- ePAPR 2.2.1 Node Names The node name follows the convention: node-name@unit-address Characters in node-name may be: 0-9         a-z A-Z ,._+- --- Linux dtc allows characters in node-name to be: 0-9      a-z A-Z ,._+-      *#? removed Feb 9 2021 by commit 9d2279e7e6ee, not yet in a dtc release Discouraged: #?.+*_

Node Name length --- ePAPR

The node-name component shall be 1 to 31 characters in length.

--- Linux

The maximun length of the node-name component is not enforced.

It has been proposed that the Devicetree Specification be updated with a maximum length that is consistent with current Linux kernel usage.

Property name --- ePAPR

2.2.4.1 Property Names Characters in the property name may be: 0-9        a-z A-Z ,._+-?#

--- Linux

dtc allows characters in property name to be: 0-9     a-z A-Z ,._+-?#     *

Discouraged: ?.+*_     # is only recommended as the first character of a property name

Label names --- ePAPR

No information on characters in label names. --- Linux

dtc allows characters in label name to be: 0-9     a-z A-Z _  The label name may not begin with 0-9

property name must not match node name

--- ePAPR No prohibition of a property name matching the name of the node containing the property. --- Linux The validation tools use a YAML format. YAML format does not allow a property name to match the name of the node containing the property. Some Apple OpenFirmware contains this sort of node name / property name collision. '''Linux does not have any node name / property name collisions. Adding''' any such collision is not allowed. This was discussed in the email thread rooted at https://www.spinics.net/lists/devicetree-spec/msg00978.html NOTE: the dtc compiler allows a property name to match the name of the node containing the property. There will not be an error when a devicetree containing a node name / property name collision is compiled. A patch to dtc to trigger a warning on node name / property name has been accepted, but is not yet in a released version.

status property
--- ePAPR

2.3.4 status 'Valid values for status are: "okay", "disabled", "fail", "fail-sss". "Refer to the device binding for details on what disabled means for      a given device.'

3.7.1 General Properties of CPU nodes Valid values for status are: "okay", "disabled".

--- Linux

A node is enabled if: status == "ok" status == "okay" status property does not exist Convention for disabling a node: status == "disabled" Not all code checks whether a node is disabled. These cases are bugs.

"ABI" stability
Are device tree bindings stable?

Well.... Let me put this open jar full of gasoline on the floor and step away for a little while. Oh, can I loan you a lighter or a book of matches?


 * See slides 8 and following from the Grant Likely presentation at the Kernel Summit 2013 discussion: [[Media:DT_Binding_Process_glikely_ksummit_2013_10_28.pdf | It's Broken! Fixing the DT binding process (PDF)]]


 * Email thread: DT bindings as ABI [was: Do we have people interested in device tree janitoring / cleanup?]


 * [[Media:The_Device_Tree_as_a_Stable_ABI-_A_Fairy_Tale?.pdf | "The Device Tree as a Stable ABI: A Fairy Tale?", ELC 2015 by Thomas Petazzoni (PDF)]]

forward and backward dts compatibility
Current practice is that
 * new kernels work with old devicetrees
 * old kernels may or may not work with new devicetrees

This means that if a binding is modified in a non-compatible manner then the kernel implementation must still recognize the old binding until old devicetrees have been obsoleted and no longer exist.

Bindings review process
devicetree/bindings/submitting-patches.txt was created following discussion at the 2013 Kernel Summit.

Email thread: [Ksummit-2013-discuss] [ATTEND] Handling of devicetree bindings

The slides that Grant Likely presented at the Kernel Summit discussion were in an email attachment that the mail list stripped. Here are the slides: [[Media:DT_Binding_Process_glikely_ksummit_2013_10_28.pdf | It's Broken! Fixing the DT binding process (PDF)]]

Slides 18 and 19 of [[Media:Rutland-presentation_3.pdf | [PDF] ]] "Device Tree, the Disaster so Far", ELC Europe 2013 by Mark Rutland.

Support of different hardware versions in a single driver
Examples of drivers that match more than one compatible string.

This list is not an endorsement of any particular technique. It is instead a (partial) list of some existing code in the Linux kernel.

The examples are not meant to capture each method entirely; they are instead meant to illustrate the basic concept.

Hardware Version in struct of_device_id.data
The hardware version is used throughout the driver to choose alternate actions.

drivers/iommu/arm-smmu.c:

static const struct of_device_id arm_smmu_of_match[] = { { .compatible = "arm,smmu-v1", .data = (void *)ARM_SMMU_V1 }, { .compatible = "arm,smmu-v2", .data = (void *)ARM_SMMU_V2 }, { .compatible = "arm,mmu-400", .data = (void *)ARM_SMMU_V1 }, { .compatible = "arm,mmu-401", .data = (void *)ARM_SMMU_V1 }, { .compatible = "arm,mmu-500", .data = (void *)ARM_SMMU_V2 }, { }, }; MODULE_DEVICE_TABLE(of, arm_smmu_of_match); static int arm_smmu_device_dt_probe(struct platform_device *pdev) {        const struct of_device_id *of_id; of_id = of_match_node(arm_smmu_of_match, dev->of_node); smmu->version = (enum arm_smmu_arch_version)of_id->data; ...        if (smmu->version > ARM_SMMU_V1) { ...        } } static struct platform_driver arm_smmu_driver = { .driver = { .name          = "arm-smmu", .of_match_table = of_match_ptr(arm_smmu_of_match), },        .probe  = arm_smmu_device_dt_probe, .remove = arm_smmu_device_remove, };

Function Call Table pointer in struct of_device_id.data
The function call table is used throughout the driver to choose alternate actions.

drivers/iio/adc/xilinx-xadc-core.c:

static const struct xadc_ops xadc_zynq_ops = { .read = xadc_zynq_read_adc_reg, .write = xadc_zynq_write_adc_reg, .setup = xadc_zynq_setup, .get_dclk_rate = xadc_zynq_get_dclk_rate, .interrupt_handler = xadc_zynq_interrupt_handler, .threaded_interrupt_handler = xadc_zynq_threaded_interrupt_handler, .update_alarm = xadc_zynq_update_alarm, }; static const struct of_device_id xadc_of_match_table[] = { { .compatible = "xlnx,zynq-xadc-1.00.a", (void *)&xadc_zynq_ops }, { .compatible = "xlnx,axi-xadc-1.00.a", (void *)&xadc_axi_ops }, { }, }; MODULE_DEVICE_TABLE(of, xadc_of_match_table); static int xadc_probe(struct platform_device *pdev) {        const struct of_device_id *id; id = of_match_node(xadc_of_match_table, pdev->dev.of_node); ...        indio_dev = devm_iio_device_alloc(&pdev->dev, sizeof(*xadc)); xadc = iio_priv(indio_dev); ...        xadc->ops = id->data; ...        ret = xadc->ops->setup(pdev, indio_dev, irq); ... } static struct platform_driver xadc_driver = { .probe = xadc_probe, .remove = xadc_remove, .driver = { .name = "xadc", .of_match_table = xadc_of_match_table, }, }; module_platform_driver(xadc_driver);

Hardware Description pointer in struct of_device_id.data
The hardware description data is used to configure the device.

This struct pointed to by struct of_device_id.data in this example includes a function call table in addition to the hardware description fields.

drivers/iio/adc/twl6030-gpadc.c:

static const struct twl6030_gpadc_platform_data twl6030_pdata = { .iio_channels = twl6030_gpadc_iio_channels, .nchannels = TWL6030_GPADC_USED_CHANNELS, .ideal = twl6030_ideal, .start_conversion = twl6030_start_conversion, .channel_to_reg = twl6030_channel_to_reg, .calibrate = twl6030_calibration, }; static const struct of_device_id of_twl6030_match_tbl[] = { {                .compatible = "ti,twl6030-gpadc", .data = &twl6030_pdata, },        {                 .compatible = "ti,twl6032-gpadc", .data = &twl6032_pdata, },        { /* end */ } }; static int twl6030_gpadc_probe(struct platform_device *pdev) {        const struct of_device_id *match; const struct twl6030_gpadc_platform_data *pdata; match = of_match_device(of_twl6030_match_tbl, dev); pdata = match->data; indio_dev = devm_iio_device_alloc(dev, sizeof(*gpadc)); gpadc = iio_priv(indio_dev); gpadc->pdata = pdata; platform_set_drvdata(pdev, indio_dev); ...        ret = pdata->calibrate(gpadc); ...        indio_dev->channels = pdata->iio_channels; indio_dev->num_channels = pdata->nchannels; }

FDT built into kernel as data
'''This mechanism is not intended for use by drivers. The use by drivers/gpu/drm/rcar-du/ has been grandfathered as an existing user before this policy was created.'''

The Linux kernel build system has a rule to automagically place an FDT in the kernel image as a binary data object. To invoke the rule, add entries to the makefile of the form XXX.dtb.o to create a data object for devicetree source file XXX.dts.

obj-y += my_system.dtb.o obj-$(CONFIG_XXX) += XXX.dtb.o DTC_FLAGS_my_system += -@
 * 1) enable export of phandle symbols to be used by another overlay

PRECIOUS was also required in the makefile until removed by commit 54a702f70589 ("kbuild: mark $(targets) as .SECONDARY and remove .PRECIOUS markers"), as of Linux kernel 4.17.

.PRECIOUS: \ $(obj)/%.dtb.S \ $(obj)/%.dtb

The data object can be accessed in the kernel through extern declarations of pointers to the beginning and just past the end of the data:

extern uint8_t __dtb_XXX_begin[]; extern uint8_t __dtb_XXX_end[];

SPECIAL CASE: devicetree source filename containing dash
The name of the devicetree source file is embedded in the pointers to the binary data object in the kernel image. A file name containing a dash can not be embedded in the pointer names because dash ("-", aka hyphen) is not a valid character in a pointer name. To resolve this problem, the build system process will convert each dash ("-") in the file name to an underscore ("_") in the pointer names.

This fixup is scheduled to be added in Linux version 4.16, 4.4.122, 4.9.88, 4.14.27, 4.15.10

defaults and inheritance of #address-cells and #size-cells
The standards used by Linux do not allow a default value for #address-cells and #size-cells. This also means that a node should not inherit the values from a predecessor in the tree.

Contrary to the standards, the Linux implementation provides both default values and inheritance.

of_n_addr_cells will search up through the devicetree until a node with the #address-cells property is found. If none is found the default value of OF_ROOT_NODE_ADDR_CELLS_DEFAULT is returned.

of_n_size_cells will search up through the devicetree until a node with the #size-cells property is found. If none is found the default value of OF_ROOT_NODE_SIZE_CELLS_DEFAULT is returned.

The values of OF_ROOT_NODE_ADDR_CELLS_DEFAULT and OF_ROOT_NODE_SIZE_CELLS_DEFAULT are normally 1, but can be changed to a difference value by architecture specific defines. Currently (Linux 4.17) overrides for sparc are 1 for OF_ROOT_NODE_SIZE_CELLS_DEFAULT and 2 for OF_ROOT_NODE_ADDR_CELLS_DEFAULT.

ePAPR 1.1, section 2.3.5, page 24

The #address-cells and #size-cells properties are not inherited from ancestors in the device tree. They shall be explicitly defined.

The Linux kernel supports a default for #address-cells and #size-cells to avoid breaking old OF based platforms which did not set them.

... the default that Linux implements does not match the one defined by the IEE1275 spec, in order to accomodate certain broken device trees on certain machines (mostly Apple, I think). The IEEE1275 default is simply 2, ... These properties were never supposed to be inherited, but apparently some old firmwares didn't get the memo. reference: Date:  Thu, 19 Jul 2018 15:37:09 +1000 From:  David Gibson  Subject: Re: [PATCH] libfdt: fdt_address_cells and fdt_size_cells Message-ID: <20180719053709.GB18205@umbus.fritz.box> List-ID: 

The dtc devicetree compiler will warn if #address-cells or #size-cells is missing. New devicetree source is expected to properly provide the values for #address-cells and #size-cells.

/chosen node vs /firmware node
The /chosen node is used by firmware to communicate boot time information to the Linux kernel.

The /firmware node is used to describe the interface that the Linux kernel can use for run-time communication with the firmware. Examples of run-time communication include secure calls, a mailbox, IPC, and hypervisor calls.

An exception to using the /firmware node for run-time communication with the firmware is if the firmware is accessed through a register based interface, in which case the firmware would be under simple-bus. [1]

The specific bindings for the /firmware nodes on various platforms are documented in the same manner as other Linux bindings.

[1] Rob Herring; aug 24, 2018; Re: Recognize "/firmware" node usage

printk format string
There are some printk format specifiers to do complicated formatting of pointers to some structures. For devicetree, there is a family of specifiers for struct device_node.

Documentation/core-api/printk-formats.rst contains a description of the format specifiers. Check printk-formats.rst for the current specification of the format specifiers.

Excerpt from Linux 4.18 printk-formats.rst:

%pOF[fnpPcCF]

For printing kobject based structs (device nodes). Default behaviour is equivalent to %pOFf.

- f - device node full_name - n - device node name - p - device node phandle - P - device node path spec (name + @unit) - F - device node flags - c - major compatible string - C - full compatible string

The separator when using multiple arguments is ':'

Examples::

%pOF   /foo/bar@0                      - Node full name %pOFf  /foo/bar@0                      - Same as above %pOFfp /foo/bar@0:10                   - Node full name + phandle %pOFfcF /foo/bar@0:foo,device:--P-     - Node full name + major compatible string + node flags D - dynamic d - detached P - Populated B - Populated bus

Notice that multiple arguments can follow '%pOF'. This has the unfortunate side effect that the current implementation of decoding the format specifier with eat the character following the final argument if that character is not detected as a boundary between specifiers, such as a space or a '%'. For example, in this snprintf, the 'T' is meant to be printed as a literal value, but is instead suppressed:

csize = snprintf(str, len, "of:N%pOFnT%s", dev->of_node,                dev->of_node->type);

For a node with name of 'name' and a null pointer for type, desired result: of:NnameT actual result:  of:Nname

A temporary workaround is to use a '%c' specifier:

csize = snprintf(str, len, "of:N%pOFn%c%s", dev->of_node,                "T",                 dev->of_node->type);

boolean property
The devicetree standards do not define a boolean type, but the Linux kernel API includes a function to determine whether a property is true or false:

The return value of of_property_read_bool is based on whether the property is present or not. The return value is not based on the value of the property. Thus the following confusing result:

a_node { flag="false"; } The result of of_property_read_bool(np, "flag") is true.

mixing devicetree and ACPI
Yeah, no

For the non-native English speaker: (emphatic, colloquial) Used sarcastically to answer "no" to a question where the negative answer should have been obvious. [1] [1] https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/yeah,_no#:~:text=(emphatic%2C%20colloquial)%20Used%20sarcastically,answer%20should%20have%20been%20obvious.

Some references from Device_tree_plumbers_2016_etherpad:
Question: what about device tree on x86
 * Answer: there's already support for DT on x86. But, we should not mix DT and ACPI.

A controversial topic is ACPI overlays (putting DT in ACPI or ACPI in DT).
 * Don't want to have drivers that get part of their info from ACPI and part from DT. That's nuts.

Question: Can you have ACPI and DT at the same time on x86?
 * Answer: No. Some ARM64 systems have support for both ACPI and DT, but the system selects one to use at runtime. They are not used at the same time.
 * You can run the DT unit tests on x86.

CONFIG_ options
Additional CONFIG_ options are unlikely to be accepted into the devicetree subsystem:

The following email fragment is copied from: https://lore.kernel.org/all/971f874c-a2b3-6fbf-99e4-3c248078e098@gmail.com/ On 2/2/22 6:15 PM, Rob Herring wrote: > On Wed, Feb 2, 2022 at 4:01 PM Frank Rowand  wrote: >> >> On 2/2/22 2:29 PM, Rob Herring wrote: >>> On Wed, Feb 2, 2022 at 12:38 PM Frank Rowand  wrote: >>>> ... >>>> I think a better solution would be to add a config option, something >>>> like CONFIG_OF_UNITTEST_VERBOSE, that would print the pass messages >>>> at loglevel KERN_ERR. I'll submit a patch for that and see what the >>>> review responses are. >>> >>> Nak for another config option. >> >> Because? > > It's another config option... Another build combination to test... > Users have to rebuild to change behavior... Thanks for the explanation. -Frank

For context, Rob and Frank are devicetree maintainers. Frank's final comment is an implicit agreement with Rob's reasoning.

Devicetree Unittests
The devicetree unittests, drivers/of/unittest.c, uses FDT, EDT, and Changesets. In many cases the usage is as described in the FDT, EDT, and Changesets general descriptions below. However there are exceptions to the general descriptions due to test requirements.

No attempt will be made here to describe the exceptions; the unittest code must be read to understand the exceptions.

FDT Flattened Device Tree
A source devicetree file, xxx.dts, is compiled into file xxx.dtb, which is in Flattened Device Tree (FDT) format.

An FDT may be provided to the Linux kernel by the bootloader, or may be linked into a special section of the kernel image.

Once overlay suppport is sufficiently complete and robust a way to load an overlay FDT from userspace might be implemented. There has been an out of mainline tree implementation for many years.

Early in the kernel boot process, before normal memory allocation is available, the FDT passed by the bootloader is copied from initial_boot_params into properly aligned memory, allocated by early_init_dt_alloc_memory_arch. initial_boot_params is changed to point to the newly allocated memory and the memory containing the FDT passed from the bootloader is not freed.

The FDT will not be freed after use because:
 * 1) The Extended Device Tree (EDT) created from the FDT will contain pointers into the FDT.
 * 2) If a new kernel image is booted via kexec (see drivers/of/kexec.c) then the FDT at initial_boot_params is copied and modified to be passed to the newly booted kernel

overlay FDT
The API to apply an overlay FDT to the System Devicetree is of_overlay_fdt_apply. The FDT passed to of_overlay_fdt_apply is copied to an overlay subsystem private copy, and thus may be freed by the caller.

The overlay subsystem private copy of the overlay FDT will not be freed after use because:
 * 1) The OF_DETACHED Extended Device Tree (EDT) created from the FDT will contain pointers into the FDT.
 * 2) The System Devicetree that the FDT is applied to will contain pointers into the FDT.
 * 3) Even if the overlay is removed, the devicetree APIs to access the System Devicetree can return pointers into the FDT and there is no way to guarantee that those pointers are no longer in use

TODO: finish this note... The above explanation is probably incomplete, misleading, and needs further elaboration. When a property is added to a changeset, in anticipation of being applied into the live devicetree, the data is copied into newly allocated memory so that the live devicetree will NOT contain a pointer into the FDT. add_changeset_property ...   __of_prop_dup new->name = kstrdup new->value = kmemdup return new ...

EDT Expanded Device Tree
An FDT is expanded into a runtime data structure, the Expanded Device Tree (EDT). The expansion is performed by __unflatten_device_tree.

__unflatten_device_tree is in the call path of:
 * unflatten_and_copy_device_tree for the FDT provided by the bootloader
 * of_overlay_fdt_apply for an overlay FDT
 * unusual ways by drivers/of/unittest.c for devicetree unittest (these unusual ways are not to be used by normal non-test kernel code)

The EDT that describes the current system is rooted at of_root. This tree may be referred to by names such as the "system devicetree", "system device tree", "live tree", "live devicetree", "live device tree", "devicetree", "device tree", in various documents and code comments.

Some of the APIs to access nodes in the system devicetree will default to starting to scan the tree at of_root if the caller specifies a starting pointer with the value of NULL.

When a new dynamic EDT is created from an FDT, the EDT is marked as OF_DETACHED. If dynamic content is added to the system devicetree, new objects are created in the system devicetree; the system devicetree will not contain pointers into an OF_DETACHED EDT. However, the newly created nodes in the system devicetree may contain pointers into the FDT that was expanded into the OF_DETACHED EDT.

CONFIG_OF_DYNAMIC
System devicetree internal data structure object lifetime is determined by CONFIG_OF_DYNAMIC.

For normal cases, CONFIG_OF_DYNAMIC is selected by other CONFIG_ options.

This information is valid as of as of Linux v6.2-rc1. The overall concepts should also apply as far back as v4.15-rc1, where commit b56b5528f5b3 "of: make kobject and bin_attribute support configurable" made device nodes (struct device_node) as kobjects configurable. Some additional portions of the concepts should apply as far back as v3.15-rc, where commit 0829f6d1f69e "of: device_node kobject lifecycle fixes" fixed some issues with struct device_node objects.

The following CONFIG_ options will select CONFIG_OF_DYNAMIC: CONFIG_MPC885ADS CONFIG_PPC_PSERIES CONFIG_I2C_DEMUX_PINCTRL CONFIG_HOTPLUG_PCI_POWERNV CONFIG_OF_OVERLAY

As a special case, CONFIG_OF_DYNAMIC can be explicitly chosen to add devicetree unittest coverage for the dynamic code, without also testing overlays, with the option: "Support for dynamic device trees"

CONFIG_OF_DYNAMIC=n
There is no concept of live devicetree object lifetime.

This is because of_node_get and of_node_put are defined as empty functions.

CONFIG_OF_DYNAMIC=y
Live devicetree object lifetime will be one of:
 * 1) exist until kernel shutdown
 * 2) exist as long as the associated dynamic devicetree node reference count is positive

Objects that are created from the boot time Flattened Device Tree (FDT) will exist until kernel shutdown.

Objects that are created via a dynamic device tree API will exist as long as the associated devicetree node reference count is positive.

How to read the pseudo-code in the following blocks: Each level of indentation represents the body of the function call on the previous line. Arguments when calling a function are enclosed with "". If the names of the arguments within the called function differ from the caller, then the function call line is duplicated, but the names of the arguments within the called function are enclosed with "[]". The pseudo code does not show the entire contents of the functions. Some functionality is abstracted into comments, pre-fixed with '//'. The actual functionality may or may not also be shown in the pseudo-code.

The kobject release function node->kobj->ktype is initialized to of_node_release when a devicetree node is created:

struct kobj_type of_node_ktype = { .release = of_node_release, };

of_node_init[node] #if defined(CONFIG_OF_KOBJ) kobject_init(&node->kobj, &of_node_ktype) kobject_init[kobj, ktype] kobj->ktype = ktype

When a devicetree node refcount becomes zero, of_node_release is called.

of_node_put[node] kobject_put(&node->kobj) kobject_put[kobj] kref_put(&kobj->kref, kobject_release) kref_put[kref, release] if (refcount_dec_and_test(&kref->refcount)) release(kref) // release is kobject_release kobj = container_of(kref, struct kobject, kref) kobject_cleanup(kobj) t = get_ktype(kobj) return kobj->ktype t->release(kobj) // t->release is of_node_release of_node_release[kobj] // kobject_cleanup might continue up the tree: //   parent will either be NULL or kobj->parent //   parent should be NULL for devicetree kobject_put(parent)

'''The memory associated with any property from an overlay that was added to a devicetree node that was created from the boot time Flattened Device Tree (FDT) will never be freed''' because the refcount of that node should never become zero. Even if the refcount of the node becomes zero, of_node_put will return without freeing anything because the node is not detached, not dynamic, and not an overlay node.

Continuing the call path from of_node_put down into of_node_release:

This is the 't->release(kobj)' in kobject_cleanup when of_node_put results in the refcount being decremented to zero:

of_node_release(kobj) // objects associated with kobj are not freed if     // any of the following is true: //   kobj is not detached //   kobj is not a dynamic node //   kobj if not an overlay node if (of_node_check_flag(node, OF_OVERLAY)) // sanity check that a changeset free of kobj is in progress if (!of_node_check_flag(node, OF_OVERLAY_FREE_CSET)) pr_err("ERROR: memory leak ...        // sanity check for unexpected properties in node         if (node->properties)            r_err("ERROR: %s, unexpected properties in ... property_list_free(node->properties) property_list_free[prop_list] // for each property in prop_list kfree(prop->name) kfree(prop->value) kfree(prop) property_list_free(node->deadprops) property_list_free[prop_list] // for each property in prop_list kfree(prop->name) kfree(prop->value) kfree(prop) fwnode_links_purge(of_fwnode_handle(node)) kfree(node->full_name) kfree(node->data) kfree(node)

Changesets
Each dynamic (run-time) change to the System Devicetree is described by a list of changeset entries (struct of_changeset_entry). Overlay apply and remove code adds another layer of data structure, the struct overlay_changeset, to describe how the overlay modifies the System Devicetree.

TODO: describe how changeset related data objects are allocated and freed.